Motivat de recenta discuție de la Cudi, m-am gândit să scriu câteva cuvinte despre Supergirl. Dar cum producătorii au reușit performanța de-a crea un serial din care nu mi-au rămas în minte decât lucruri vagi, o să încropesc recenzia de față din titlurile și notele acordate de ceilalți recenzori de pe IMDb. Vorbim de oameni simpli, care și-au făcut cont acolo și și-au argumentat calificativele acordate, nu de critici plătiți. O să-i citez pe primii, de sus în jos, fără să sar peste niciunul. Sortarea lor este implicită, după cât de mult i-au apreciat cititorii. Așadar, să începem:
ken-1273, nota 4: Becoming more like a soap
wsl7, nota 4: Bad writers
jp7570, nota 3: What once had potential has become predictable and lazy
Steel Trap Mind, nota 1: SHOW, don’t tell!
mama-stuhr, nota 1: I’m done…
DcTvGiRl2000, nota 1: Unispiring with Terrible, Inconsistent Writing
irakliskosso, nota 1: Isn’t there a 0 star rating?
brileearch, nota 1: From bad to worse
nicholscody, nota 1: Supergirl sucks harder than my Kirby
Am căutat pe Google: Kirby este numele unui aspirator. Comentariul:
If your interested in watching a super hero show that’s more interested in pushing political crap than super hero adventure this shows for you.
meneermalik-1, nota 2: Don’t bother. It had potential but it keeps getting worse and worse
ScypherB, nota 2: Not a great show
okjake-43351, nota 1: I wish I didn’t hate it
Deci, nu toți sunt hateri, unii chiar și-au dorit să le placă. Mărturisesc că mă număr printre ei.
ckennow, nota 1: Reality Check
Manuel Suazo, nota 3: Trash trash, trash, trash
matthiasn-1, nota 2: Bad writing meets bad acting
The second season is even worse than the first one.
Unfortunately the series doesn’t manage to make any connection with the characters, the writing is really bad. Unlogical plots, undeveloped character arcs and no meaningful story at all, just pathetic dialogues.
At least some of the fighting scenes are quite OK.
abrahamyan-armen, nota 1: Awful !!!
gahvno, nota 1: Shark, meet Jumped.
caxuxo, nota 1: Super Ridiculous
SuperGirlSanversKarolsen, nota 1: What a Train-wreck…than not even Supergirl herself could save at this point
Petar Stamenkovic, nota 5: Season 3 has turned into full ideological propaganda
Eric Lazarian, nota 3: It started out with great potential… but…
Eu am văzut doar 7-8 episoade din primul sezon, și am considerat că e foarte prost.
Mohsen GG, nota 1: I tried so hard
aamerkastoff, nota 1: Its a Bird, Its a Plane, Its Feminist Propaganda Girl.
Llinos Dafys, fara nota: Recapturing our youth
Ăsta e singurul comentariu pozitiv de pe pagină.
stephjean47, nota 1: Beware…Supergirl is neither Empowering nor Inspiring
Cu asta s-a terminat prima pagină. Să o deschidem și pe a doua:
michaelstokoe-84784, nota 3: Inept writers
JaneDoe1983, nota 2: Supergirl is a Super…No.
JennieScribesAlot, nota 1: Watch Only if You Support Sexism, Misogyny, Slave Owning, and Endless Political Propaganda Thinly Veiling Itself as “Life Lessons”
jimsboatworks26, nota 1: James Olsen…. really?
vanessasimpleton, nota 1: A Disappointing, Non-Feminist Show and a Disservice to the Supergirl Comics
Silver The BabyDoll, nota 1: Completely Awful
jm101010, nota 1: Started off decent, then became the worst show I’ve ever watched
alecshot, nota 2: Weak
kazallaz, nota 2: Is it a superhero show or a llove story
shandibarton, nota 1: Awful
ochakor, nota 3: awkward awkward awkward…
sonerayanlar, nota 1: Worst series ever
mtusa-30122, nota 1: should be canceled
Redau comentariul lui mtusa-30122:
I watched with my 15 year old 4 times, trying to give it a chance. Horrible b rated acting (except a couple people like the miscast Jimmy Olson, great actor but the show may ruin his career. Every week its a politically correct love affair, aliens vs humans, black& white, gay, many political biased statements, even on Mars there were black and white martians, the white martians of course bad. supergirl, the actress is horrible. The “super powers” have no original basis, she gets her butt kicked constantly without green kryptonite. The show follows zero of the script of any original series/comic edition. My daughter at first laughed, then 3rd show we made fun of and now its dumped for anything of value. Every character is miscast. This supergirl should be cast a librarian or church secretary. Jimmy Olson was known for being a nerd, red headed love struck weakling, not a black great looking stud who also turns superhero. Now her adopted sister and her girlfriend on this show could pull off a series. cbs, you have great shows like Ransom, what the heck
momal-mahar, nota 2: One of the most cringe-worthy shows ever
sm6451, nota 1: SJW girl = Garbage and Supergirl 90210
roger-huddle, nota 1: Super drival
andy221-237-463495, nota 1: Political After School Special
rojobaron-197-234498, nota 1: From mediocrity to don’t bother
elnora-55317, nota 1: Why is this show still on?
bendramsey, nota 4: Annoying
stonebrake, nota 5: Slowly getting worse
Lyft Man, nota 1: In the beginning it was tolerable and now it’s crap.
Knight Hawk, nota 3: I’d rather my daughter grow up to be General Zod
Și mă opresc, că or fi de ajuns. Redau mai jos comentariul integral al lui Knight Hawk:
This is a terrible show. It’s disheartening to see so many people regard Supergirl as a positive female role model. She’s exactly the opposite.
Supergirl is not heroic and not someone to look up to or emulate. She constantly requires that everyone around her make enormous personal sacrifices on her behalf. She continually relies on the men in her life to do all of the smart stuff and hard work. She incessantly complains that everything in her life isn’t handed to her on a silver platter even though she’s SUPERGIRL and therefore deserves it. She doesn’t want to earn people’s respect, she believe she’s entitled to it. She’s a taker, not a giver. She falls to pieces at the drop of a hat. She repeatedly gives up when things don’t go her way and everyone has to practically force her to go back to doing super things. She does not care much for the other people in her life. Even when she does help people, her motives are purely self aggrandizing. Her greatest ambition is to continue making coffee for someone who actually does want to make something of herself.
The other characters are shallow and vapid. They’re not people in their own right. It’s almost as if they’re marionettes dancing around Supergirl, their entire existence is solely for the purpose of…well, it would just look awkward if Supergirl was the only character in the show.
Any normal mundane person is more heroic in their real life than Supergirl is in her own show. Look to Peggy Carter or Katniss Everdeen for your positive female role models. When life doesn’t give them what they want, they don’t rely on their male friends to make things better. They step up, take charge, not only make their own situation better, but make things better for everyone around them, especially the people who aren’t able to do so for themselves.
If it wasn’t for her powers, Supergirl wouldn’t even be buying coffee for her boss. She’d be an unemployed delinquent smoking pot all the time with absolutely no direction to her life as her friends and family desperately try in vain to get her life back on track.
Teach your children to study and work hard. They should aspire to be doctors, nurses, engineers, scientists, teachers, mathematicians, artists, poets, writers, fire fighters, law enforcement, social workers, builders and countless other professions. They should be thinkers, leaders, people who serve their communities.
They don’t need to be self-pitying, self-aggrandizing, shallow, selfish, needy narcissists.
Ce aș putea adăuga?